My first introduction to Martin McDonagh was through his film In Bruges, a poignant look at guilt in the aftermath of a horribly botched assassination. Two pros are sent posthaste after their job from London to the titular city in Belgium to lie low for a while and take in the sights. Midway through, one of them receives a secondary assignment: kill his companion, whose first and only hit resulted in disastrous collateral damage. There’s an older gentleman, a young upstart, and their volatile handler who must get involved when his instructions aren’t followed. There’s even a young woman who catches a man’s fancy who eventually needs protection from what’s happening. McDonagh’s script fully fleshes them out into tangible characters whose actions and consequences are felt, not just seen, and we wind up sympathizing with the two as they’re hunted by their handler.
To a certain extent, McDonagh has replicated this formula with Wild Horse Nine, adhering mostly to the same setup but throwing a few differentiating wrinkles into the mix. Once again, we’ve got a young and old twosome—this time, they’re CIA spooks—traveling to another country and looking at the sights while one of them gets the order to kill the other, and their handler has to step in. This time, though, it’s the younger man tasked with eliminating an older statesman, someone who may or may not have one of the most incriminating pieces of evidence in American history. And much like In Bruges, Wild Horse Nine has a grand time drawing us into its solemnity while choosing precise moments to spike the punch it’s given us.
One thing I’ve always liked about McDonagh’s films is his ability to push his characters via the spoken word and inference, not outright action, thus making actual violence more shocking. Between John Malkovich, Sam Rockwell, and Steve Buscemi, there’s a lot of dialogue that flies around, but it’s Coen Brothers-esque in that some of it’s consequential, some of it’s frivolous, but all of it has a way of sharply defining each character and their purposes. As it’s set in the months before the 1973 Chilean coup d’etat, there’s an automatic layer of tension in the background, and we’re not exactly sure how to take Chris Carlisle (Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Rockwell) at first, but McDonagh likes to slow-roll us and reward us for our patience in this regard as his story unfolds.
Chris is in his last days as a CIA operative, and he’s also in the last months of his life, having been diagnosed with terminal cancer. One of his last wishes—that is, after he and Lee have laid the groundwork for the authoritarian regime to take power in Chile—is to go to Easter Island to “look at the heads” and have a little vacation. Lee goes along with him, intending to follow their superior MJ’s (Buscemi) order to take care of Chris, and it ain’t setting him up in hospice or a nursing home; think about the use of the phrase “take care of” that Jules Winnfield demonstrates in Pulp Fiction by the elevator. But Chris might also know the whereabouts of evidence of a certain assassination in 1963, and MJ wants to know what he’s got. So between this and the mounting unrest fomented in Chile—personified by protestor Monica (Miranda di Girolamo) and her friend Alicia (Ailín Salas), both of whom Chris and Lee encounter in Chile and again on Easter Island—there’s a lot to juice this story of friendship, salvation, and redemption, and you’d expect a lot of sparks and conflict, yes?
That’s the thing: McDonagh doesn’t go that route. Sure, there are scenes which more than adequately show the opposing factions and the kind of adversarial dyads we expect, but Wild Horse Nine is more about the fleeting moments that we want to last a lifetime in the face of said lifetime ending rapidly. A friend that won’t quit on you; a night out enjoying the company of strangers and music; the majesty of horses and their unexpected meaning in our lives; and maybe the thrill of the chase or danger. John Malkovich embodies this in his ethereal performance, giving Chris a lifetime of wounds that never healed or that he doesn’t care about enough to want to heal. Instead, he knows that whatever he does is inconsequential and won’t matter once the cancer robs what’s left of his mind and life, and he wants his last memories to be of something larger than he is, something that negates the supposed grandeur of doing things for the greater good. Of course, he has to dodge a few flying bullets and double-crosses, but what’s life without that?
Conversely, Sam Rockwell gives Lee the gregarious-but-aloof presence that Rockwell can be counted upon to deliver, but there’s more of a point to his glad-handing, smooth-over-everything persona. Not only does he have to deal with Chris, whose memory is fading and whose whims are getting a little annoying, but he also has to deal with MJ breathing down his neck to finish the job. He’s definitely the voice of the younger generation here, but only if that younger generation relishes sowing a little bit of chaos here and there. It’s almost as if the time on Easter Island is getting to him, that he’d rather be out where the action is instead of cooling his heels and waiting for something to happen. Between Chris and Lee, there’s a wonderful “this is how we used to do it” panache versus “let’s just get the job done” urgency that comes to loggerheads at every turn of the movie, and both of them lock us into their clandestine dance.
There’s something magnetic in the devil-may-care whimsy that Martin McDonagh gives to his characters and to the movie itself. It’s the looming prospect of Chris’ death giving him the unparalleled freedom to act out in his own particular fashion, and he’s choosing to give a thinly-veiled middle finger to MJ and everyone else who might want him dead. Also, it’s his wont to live on his own schedule, thus putting that middle finger up Lee’s nose just a bit to annoy him; to Lee’s credit, he’s tasked with balancing his orders with his loyalty to Lee, and Sam Rockwell does admirably in this effort. Wild Horse Nine comes off as a not-your-standard buddy movie, owing to its pull-pull outweighing the push-pull you think McDonagh would be stacking his deck with. Instead, it’s a sunlit foray into the last days of someone who simply wants to remember what it’s like to be human again after years of unsavoriness, played impeccably by its actors and delivered with invisible strength under its chill overtones.

